Terms checked October 25, 2026. This is a comparison of standard U.S. self-directed accounts, not a ranking. Broker links are official research sources, not affiliate links. Prices, eligibility and features can change; verify the account agreement and order preview before acting.
For educational purposes only. Not financial advice. A low-cost account can make investing easier, but the account does not decide what to buy or protect a stock from falling. By the end of this lesson, you should be able to separate the account’s tax rules, the broker’s services and the investments held inside it—and write a comparison that another person can check.
First choose the account’s job, then compare providers
A brokerage account is the arrangement through which you hold cash and securities. The brokerage is the provider. A stock, bond or fund is a holding. These are three different decisions. Someone can open a Roth IRA at a brokerage, deposit money and still own no stock or fund because the money remains in the account’s cash position.
The label Roth IRA describes tax treatment, not an investment return. The same eligible ETF might be available in a Roth IRA and a taxable account. Its market price can fall in either. Conversely, two Roth IRAs at different firms can hold very different investments and take very different risks. “I bought a Roth” does not tell you what you own.
| Label | What it is for | Question to resolve before funding |
|---|---|---|
| Taxable brokerage account | Investing outside an IRA’s contribution and retirement-distribution framework. Investment income and realized gains can have tax consequences. | When might I need the money, and what records will I need for taxes? |
| Traditional IRA | A retirement account. A contribution may be deductible; deductible contributions and earnings generally become taxable when distributed. | Am I eligible to contribute, and separately, can I deduct this contribution? |
| Roth IRA | A retirement account funded without a contribution deduction. Qualified distributions are tax-free when IRS requirements are satisfied. | Does my income permit the intended contribution, and do I understand the distribution rules? |
| Rollover IRA | Usually an IRA receiving eligible retirement-plan assets. The tax character of the source and destination matters. | What is moving, from which plan, by which transfer process, and with what tax treatment? |
Account type and service level also differ. A self-directed account makes you responsible for investment decisions. An advisory or managed account may choose or manage holdings and charge a different fee. A broker’s $0 self-directed trade advertisement is not a quote for its advisory service. Confirm that the fee schedule you read names the account you are actually opening.
Cash and margin are another distinction. A cash account uses available funds; margin introduces borrowing and additional rules. An attractive interface or a preselected option does not make borrowing appropriate. Our account mechanics guide explains permissions, settlement and investor-protection limits in greater depth. This lesson focuses on comparing providers and IRA choices.
Account and tax background: IRS Topic 451 and IRS Roth IRA overview.
The 2026 IRA checks: limit, compensation and income
For 2026, the regular contribution limit across all your traditional and Roth IRAs combined is $7,500, or $8,600 if age 50 or older, subject to taxable-compensation limits and other eligibility rules. Opening accounts at two firms does not double that amount. The IRA limit is separate from the workplace 401(k) employee limit. Eligible rollover contributions do not use this regular annual IRA contribution allowance.
Three questions prevent a common mistake: How much taxable compensation supports a contribution? Does modified adjusted gross income (MAGI), using the relevant IRS definition, restrict a direct Roth contribution? If contributing to a traditional IRA, is the contribution deductible? Being allowed to contribute and being allowed to deduct are separate tests. Workplace-plan coverage for you or a spouse can affect the deduction.
| Rule | Filing situation | Phaseout range |
|---|---|---|
| Direct Roth contribution | Single or head of household | $153,000–$168,000 |
| Direct Roth contribution | Married filing jointly | $242,000–$252,000 |
| Traditional contribution deduction | Single contributor covered by a workplace retirement plan | $81,000–$91,000 |
| Traditional contribution deduction | Married filing jointly; contributor covered by a workplace plan | $129,000–$149,000 |
| Traditional contribution deduction | Married filing jointly; contributor not covered, spouse covered | $242,000–$252,000 |
A phaseout means a benefit or permitted contribution is reduced across a range; it is not simply “everyone below the upper number gets the full amount.” Married-filing-separately rules require particular care, including whether spouses lived together. Use the applicable IRS worksheet rather than interpolating a personal limit from this table. If neither spouse is covered by a workplace retirement plan, these workplace-coverage deduction phaseouts do not apply.
Practice: two accounts, one shared limit
Fictional reader Lena is 32, has $50,000 of eligible compensation and qualifies for a full direct Roth contribution. She has already made $2,000 of regular 2026 traditional IRA contributions. Her remaining combined allowance is $7,500 − $2,000 = $5,500, not another $7,500. Whether the $2,000 is deductible is a different question. Moving an existing eligible retirement balance does not create an additional regular contribution.
For a rollover, compare the existing plan and destination before moving anything: costs, available investments, services, withdrawal rules and protection can differ. An eligible direct rollover or trustee-to-trustee transfer can avoid handling a distribution yourself, but the applicable process depends on the source and destination. A traditional-to-Roth conversion can create taxable income. Do not assume every transfer is tax-free or that a broker’s “rollover” button settles the tax analysis.
Sources: IRS contribution and compensation limits, 2026 limits and phaseouts, Notice 2025-67, pages 4–5 (PDF), Publication 590-A and calculation worksheets, and IRS rollover guidance. For workplace-plan choices, continue with our 401(k) lesson.
Six providers: compare the service you will actually use
All six firms below offer self-directed taxable investing and traditional/Roth IRA choices. The table is a starting record, not a scorecard or an endorsement. It covers ordinary U.S. retail terms checked on the stated date. Institutional, advisory, foreign-market, telephone-assisted, promotional and special-tier arrangements can differ. The links go to the providers’ official documents; no broker referral codes have been added.
A useful comparison holds the planned activity constant. If your plan is a monthly online ETF purchase, compare that exact ETF’s availability, fractional and recurring-order rules, cash funding and total cost. If a feature is not in your plan, its presence should not automatically outweigh a fee or limitation that you will encounter. “Many features” and “a workable process for me” are different findings.
On a narrow screen, scroll the table sideways. Keyboard users can focus the table region and use the arrow keys.
| Provider | Online stock/ETF commission scope | Opening minimum and account-cost qualifications | Retirement account availability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fidelity | $0 online U.S. stock and most ETF trades; selected ETF purchases carry a service fee of 5% of trade value, capped at $100.Fidelity commissions and fees · Fidelity Brokerage Commission and Fee Schedule · Fidelity ETFs Subject to Service Fee | $0 retail brokerage/IRA opening minimum and no ordinary account fee; investment and transaction charges still apply.Fidelity account directory | Traditional, Roth and Rollover IRAs are offered.Fidelity account directory |
| Charles Schwab | $0 online U.S. exchange-listed stock/ETF trades; U.S. OTC equities are $6.95 online.Schwab pricing | $0 opening/maintenance fees and $0 account minimum for standard individual/joint brokerage and Traditional/Roth/Rollover IRA.Schwab pricing | Traditional, Roth and Rollover IRAs; Inherited and Custodial IRAs also listed.Schwab IRA accounts |
| Vanguard | $0 online stock/ETF commission; sale transaction fees and fund expenses remain.Vanguard commission and fee schedules | $0 brokerage opening minimum. A $25 annual account service fee may apply; specified full e-delivery enrollment or other qualifying conditions waive it.Vanguard brokerage account opening minimum · Vanguard commission and fee schedules | Traditional, Roth and Rollover IRAs are offered; IRA opening carries no fee.Vanguard IRA accounts |
| E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley | $0 for online U.S.-listed stock and ETF trades.E*TRADE pricing and rates | No IRA account minimum or annual IRA fee. Standard brokerage has no minimum initial deposit; it must be funded within 30 days to remain open. Transaction and service charges can apply.E*TRADE traditional IRA · E*TRADE standard-account FAQ on brokerage offer page | Traditional and Roth IRAs available.E*TRADE traditional IRA · E*TRADE Roth IRA |
| Merrill Edge Self-Directed | $0 online stock and ETF commission in the Self-Directed account.Merrill pricing | No investment minimum for Self-Directed general/IRA accounts; no annual account fee or balance minimum.Merrill pricing · Ways to invest with Merrill | Traditional, Roth and inherited IRAs listed.Merrill pricing |
| Robinhood Financial | $0 commission for U.S.-listed securities, including ETFs, via self-directed brokerage app/web trading.Robinhood Financial Standard Pricing Fee Schedule | No minimum to open or maintain the brokerage account. Optional Gold: $5/month or $50/year. Confirm IRA-specific and managed-product terms separately.Robinhood Financial Form CRS conversation starters · Robinhood Gold overview | Traditional and Roth IRAs available.Robinhood retirement |
Read “$0 opening minimum” carefully. It can mean you may establish the account with no deposit; it does not mean every mutual fund or security has a $0 purchase minimum. Likewise, $0 online stock commission does not cover every security type. A zero base options commission can coexist with a per-contract fee. Mutual funds may have purchase, short-term redemption or underlying fund expenses. Check the security’s actual order preview and the current schedule.
Commission-free is only one line of the cost record
Write down five separate cost categories: the trade commission; account or subscription charges; investment expenses; execution costs such as the bid-ask spread; and one-time actions such as a transfer or assisted order. Taxes are a separate consequence, not a brokerage commission. A fee waiver should appear with its condition, not as an unconditional zero.
An expense ratio belongs to the fund, not the tax label of your account. Fund expenses reduce fund returns; they are not necessarily a separate bill in your transaction history. Two providers can both charge $0 for an ETF trade while the selected funds have different ongoing costs. A low expense ratio also does not make different portfolios interchangeable: holdings and risks still matter.
Suppose an unrelated hypothetical account charges $25 annually unless a condition is met. On a $500 balance, $25 ÷ $500 = 5%; on $10,000 it is 0.25%. That arithmetic explains why fixed fees matter to small accounts. It does not prove that a provider with such a charge is unsuitable: the applicable waiver, other services and intended use still need checking. Record both the dollar amount and the rule that determines whether you pay it.
Cost framework: SEC investor bulletin on investment fees and expenses. Compare fund structure and holdings in our ETF lesson.
Check where cash sits and how small purchases work
After a deposit, inspect the cash position’s name and agreement. Is it a bank sweep, a money-market fund, or brokerage-held cash? What enrollment, balance thresholds and account types apply? A quoted yield may change and may depend on a paid subscription. A money-market mutual fund is a security, not an FDIC-insured bank deposit. Bank-sweep insurance depends on program conditions and deposits already held at the same banks.
Robinhood illustrates why this needs an exact source rather than a blanket statement. Its current high-yield cash documentation says eligible uninvested cash up to $10,000 in aggregate remains brokerage-held free-credit cash; eligible amounts above that threshold enter the bank sweep. Gold and enrollment requirements apply to the self-directed taxable high-yield program; IRA treatment differs. That is not the same claim as “all idle Robinhood cash is swept to insured banks.” Verify the current cash-program terms and deposit-sweep explanation.
SIPC protection and FDIC deposit insurance address different circumstances; neither makes an ordinary stock-market loss reimbursable. Our account guide explains that distinction. For this comparison, the practical task is to identify the legal cash arrangement and its conditions before treating an advertised rate or protection label as a benefit.
Fractional shares can let a small dollar amount buy part of an eligible share. But eligibility, minimum order size, supported order types, recurring purchases and transfers differ. Dividend reinvestment that creates a fraction does not necessarily mean you can place a new fractional order in any security. Check both the purchase and eventual exit process.
On a narrow screen, scroll the table sideways. Keyboard users can focus the table region and use the arrow keys.
| Provider | Fractional purchase scope | Published outgoing-transfer terms |
|---|---|---|
| Fidelity | From $1 for eligible NMS-listed stocks/ETFs; day market/limit orders execute during normal hours. Fractions cannot transfer to another broker and must be sold.Fidelity fractional-share eligibility and limitations | Published transfer-of-assets fee: $0. IRA closeout fee: $0. Receiving-firm charges are separate.Fidelity commissions and fees |
| Charles Schwab | Most U.S.-listed stocks AND ETFs from $1; eligible accounts/order limits apply. Only whole shares transfer externally; remaining fractions are liquidated.Schwab fractional shares | Full outbound transfer: $50/account. Partial outbound transfer: $0.Schwab Pricing Guide for Individual Investors |
| Vanguard | Vanguard ETFs from $1. Non-Vanguard ETFs and individual stocks generally require a whole-share purchase; dividend reinvestment is a separate feature.Vanguard self-directed account and investment minimums | May charge $100 for account closure/full transfer to another firm. ACH/Electronic Bank Transfers excluded; specified $5 million, wealth or advisory waivers apply.Vanguard commission and fee schedules |
| E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley | Eligible listed stocks/ETFs, up to three share decimals and $5 minimum notional. Rollout and security restrictions apply; direct dollar-notional order entry is not yet offered.E*TRADE fractional shares | Full outgoing account transfer: $75. Confirm partial-transfer treatment before requesting it.E*TRADE pricing and rates |
| Merrill Edge Self-Directed | Eligible dividend reinvestment can produce fractions. The primary sources reviewed did not establish direct fractional-order availability; ask the firm about the intended security. Fractional remainders may be liquidated on transfer.Merrill dividend-reinvestment form · Merrill Edge Self-Directed terms | Full transfer: $49.95; partial: $0. Internal transfers excluded. Confirm IRA closeout treatment rather than assuming two charges.Merrill pricing |
| Robinhood Financial | Eligible stock/ETF fractional orders from $1, entered by dollars or shares. Not every security qualifies; fractions cannot transfer to another broker.Robinhood fractional shares | Outgoing ACATS transfer: $100 for a partial or full transfer. Fractional holdings do not transfer in kind.Robinhood transfer assets out |
A transfer-out fee and the treatment of fractions answer different questions. Whole shares might move in kind while fractions are sold; a sale in a taxable account can have tax consequences. Ask whether the receiving firm can accept each position, whether recurring orders must be restarted, and how statements and cost-basis records will be delivered. Do not infer that a firm’s free transfer-in offer makes transfers out free.
Cash distinctions: SEC cash-sweep investor bulletin. The broker-specific source links in each table support the dated terms.
Three fictional decisions without a “best broker” shortcut
Sam: $40 each month, before choosing a fund
Sam wants to compare a regular small investment. The first record should name the account type, the proposed security and the monthly amount. If the security’s whole-share price exceeds $40, fractional eligibility matters. Sam checks whether the selected fund supports the intended purchase and recurring process, then tests the funding steps. A provider’s support for some fractional ETFs does not establish support for Sam’s exact choice.
The unresolved question is not “Which app has the most downloads?” It is “Can I carry out this plan with the selected security, account and amount, and understand each cost?” Sam should also know how to pause an automatic contribution before a bank balance becomes insufficient.
Morgan: a retirement rollover and a new contribution
Morgan has an old workplace balance and also wants to add this year’s earned income. Those are separate transactions. Morgan records the old plan’s tax character and distribution options, compares staying in the plan with the intended IRA, and confirms the direct-transfer procedure. The regular contribution needs a tax-year designation and eligibility check. Morgan does not use the account’s combined balance as evidence that an annual contribution limit was exceeded: prior assets and eligible rollover money are different from new regular contributions.
Ari: “free” account versus the services actually needed
Ari expects to need telephone assistance and occasionally transfer securities. A headline online commission is incomplete for that use. Ari checks assisted-order charges, support hours, accessible statements and transfer costs, then writes down which services are essential. If a broker offers a temporary bonus, Ari treats the hold period, qualifying deposits, subscription and repayment conditions as a separate contract rather than subtracting a headline bonus from all future costs.
These records can produce different reasonable shortlists because the needs differ. A comparison becomes useful when another reader can follow the assumptions and identify what remains unverified. It becomes weaker when a single score hides unresolved account eligibility, a fee waiver or the security actually being bought.
A broker-choice worksheet you can keep
Compare two providers using the same proposed activity. Paste the exact source URL and check date beside each material fact. Write “not verified” instead of guessing. Do not put passwords, account numbers, Social Security numbers or private tax documents here. This worksheet stays in this page’s memory and is not automatically saved; download or copy it before leaving.
You can also select and copy the worksheet text.
Before opening an account, use the provider’s genuine website, verify the firm through FINRA BrokerCheck and review its relationship summary and agreement. Confirm legal ownership, beneficiaries where relevant, cash/margin permissions and security settings. Keep the fee document with its date. After funding, check the tax year, contribution designation and cash position; after an intended investment, confirm the holding appears on the statement. Opening, funding and investing are separate checkpoints.
Check your understanding
1. A $0 commission IRA is funded with $1,000. What investment does it own?
You cannot tell from those facts. The money may still be cash, or a holding may have been purchased. Check positions and transaction history. The IRA label identifies an account’s tax framework, not its asset allocation.
2. A person puts $4,000 into a traditional IRA and $4,000 into a Roth in 2026. Is two-account ownership enough to permit that?
No. For someone under 50, $8,000 exceeds the $7,500 combined regular limit before considering compensation or Roth income restrictions. Age, eligibility, contribution type and tax-year designation must be checked; the number of brokers does not increase the allowance.
3. A $25 annual fee is waived by a condition you have not satisfied. What should the comparison show?
The $25 applicable charge and the exact waiver condition, with the source and date. An unfulfilled waiver is not a zero fee. If you later satisfy the condition, update the record rather than assuming retroactive treatment.
4. Both firms support fractional investing. Are they equivalent for a $20 ETF purchase?
Not necessarily. Confirm the exact ETF, account, minimum order size, supported order method and recurring-purchase rules at each. Also check how remaining fractions are treated if you move the account.
Core checkpoint: explain what you found
Explain why a zero commission does not establish zero total cost, distinguish a contribution from a transfer, and attach a source and check date to a provider feature. Resolve current eligibility and tax questions before applying the comparison to yourself.
You can stop with that record and choose a next step below, or continue with the optional extensions.
Choose your next practical stepOptional deeper practice
Audit contribution labels before comparing balances
An IRA can receive new contributions, transferred retirement assets and investment income. Adding every incoming dollar together does not identify the amount subject to the regular contribution limit. Create a ledger with four columns: transaction date, amount, transaction type and designated tax year. Keep the custodian’s confirmation beside it.
IRS Publication 590-A explains that a regular contribution for a year generally can be made through that year’s return-filing due date, without extensions, and that the year should be identified when contributing during the overlap with the following year. Do not assume a January bank-transfer date settles the tax-year designation. Check the applicable deadline and custodian instructions; this example does not supply a future filing date.
A fictional ledger with money arriving for different reasons
Assume Kai is 35, has sufficient eligible compensation and qualifies for the full 2026 IRA allowance. Kai contributes $2,500 to a traditional IRA during 2026. In the following January, Kai makes a separate $1,000 regular contribution expressly designated for 2026 and another $500 designated for the new year. The account also receives an $8,000 trustee-to-trustee transfer of an existing traditional IRA and earns $300 of investment income.
| Ledger entry | Amount | Counts toward Kai’s 2026 regular limit? |
|---|---|---|
| Regular contribution made during 2026 | $2,500 | Yes |
| Later contribution validly designated for 2026 | $1,000 | Yes |
| Contribution designated for the following year | $500 | No; check that year separately |
| Existing IRA moved trustee to trustee | $8,000 | No new regular contribution |
| Investment income inside the IRA | $300 | No new regular contribution |
The 2026 regular total is $3,500, leaving $7,500 − $3,500 = $4,000 under the stated assumptions. The five ledger entries total $12,300, which answers a different question. This is not Kai’s ending balance unless there was no opening balance or other activity. Nor does a correctly designated traditional contribution establish that it is deductible.
What would invalidate the simple $4,000 answer?
An additional regular contribution at another firm, insufficient eligible compensation, an incorrect tax-year designation or an applicable eligibility restriction could change it. Record unknown information before treating the remainder as permission to contribute. If an error has already occurred, ask the custodian about the appropriate correction process rather than assuming an ordinary withdrawal fixes its tax reporting.
Test a subscription against the benefit you would actually use
A paid tier can also require arithmetic. Imagine two otherwise comparable cash arrangements with fictional simple annual rates of 2.0% and 3.5%; access to the higher rate costs $60 a year. These are teaching assumptions, not any provider’s advertised rates or a statement that the protections are identical.
The rate difference is 1.5 percentage points. On a constant $2,500 balance, the additional annual interest would be $37.50 before taxes, leaving the interest benefit $22.50 below the subscription charge. On $8,000, the difference would be $120, or $60 after that charge. The arithmetic break-even balance is $60 ÷ 0.015 = $4,000.
That threshold is not a recommendation to hold $4,000 in cash. Rates can change; the balance may fluctuate; fees, taxes, compounding and access conditions can differ. Other benefits matter only if they are useful to you. Compare the actual legal cash arrangement, available alternatives and cancellation terms before assigning value to a subscription.
Complete two separate conclusions in the comparison worksheet: “My contribution record is consistent because ___” and “This paid feature costs ___ for a benefit I estimate at ___ under these assumptions.” Keeping those records separate prevents a promotional feature from distracting from account eligibility or tax-year errors.
Added exercises checked November 1, 2026. Sources: IRS 2026 IRA limits, Publication 590-A, and the SEC’s cash-sweep questions. Existing broker-specific comparisons retain their stated October 25 source date.
Sources and editorial scope
Provider terms were checked against each firm’s own pricing, account and product documentation on October 25, 2026. Links beside the comparison facts identify the applicable sources; IRS and SEC sources are linked beside the tax and cost explanations. Fictional readers, balances and funds are explicitly labeled teaching examples, not customer testimonials or predictions. We do not select a broker for you, rate customer service from untested experience or claim that an account guarantees returns.
This lesson is prepared by My Dog Picks Stocks using AI-assisted research and drafting with source and arithmetic checks described in our editorial standards. If a provider changes a term or a source contradicts this snapshot, follow the current official agreement and use the site’s correction process.
